I am sure everyone has seen traces of black discoloration on sweet peppers. On jalapenos it seems to be very common, in fact some people actually prefer jalapenos with some black showing on the surface. But is it a defect? Does the black discoloration on sweet peppers “materially affect the appearance?”
What would you do if you encountered some green, sweet peppers, but they arrived looking like the peppers in the above image? I don’t think anyone would disagree that the appearance is definitely affected. I would bet if these peppers were on display in a store the consumers would select the green sweet peppers first, bypassing the peppers with the black discoloration.
So, I have asked a lot of questions, but what is the answer? Is the black discoloration a defect for the U.S. No. 1 Grade? The USDA says “No.” Let’s look at this a little further. If a green sweet pepper shows a trace of red, the pepper is scored as a defect, as Turning Red. If the sweet pepper shows sunburn, affecting more than 15% of the surface, the pepper is scored as a defect. But if the black color affects a pepper it is never scored as a defect. What if the black discoloration affected over 50% of the surface of the sweet pepper? Still not a defect.
The following is taken from the USDA’s Inspection Instructions for Sweet Peppers:
Inspectors may encounter lots and/or loads of peppers with a large number of very dark or black areas, usually starting at the blossom end and covering a considerable portion of the pepper. This is a pigmentation of the pepper and is thought to be a varietal characteristic occurring in some growing areas. These peppers shall not be scored against any of the grades. If the applicant insists on including a description of this factor on the inspection certificate, it shall be reported under “Remarks” in general terms, followed by the word, “not affecting grade,” and “reported at applicant’s request.”
Cut and dry, the black discoloration is never scored as a defect. I realize the black discoloration does not lead to decay, does not affect the flavor of the pepper, but I am not convinced the black discoloration does not affect the marketability of the sweet peppers. I’d love to hear your thoughts, should the black discoloration be a defect if the area affected is greater than 15% (scoring guideline for sunburn), 25%, 33%, etc?